Critical COVID lessons – what we must do better if there’s a “next time” – Full Ep 435
When the history of COVID is finally written with honesty—not fear, not political spin, not bureaucratic self-preservation—it will read like a case study in how entire nations surrendered reason to panic. And if there’s one message hammered home in this week’s episode of The Other Side, it’s this: Australia’s governments have not learned the lessons they should have. In fact, the same political class that imposed unprecedented restrictions on our liberties is now quietly preparing to do it all again.
Damian Coorey’s conversation with Professor Gigi Foster and Professor James Allan is a bracing, no-nonsense unpacking of what went wrong, why it went wrong, and why the people in charge refuse to admit it. It’s the kind of frank assessment you won’t hear on the ABC, and it’s essential viewing for anyone who cares about freedom, truth, and the future of responsible government in Australia.
Coorey opens the show reflecting on the state of long-form independent media—how difficult it is to survive when most Australians won’t even click “subscribe”, let alone chip in a few bucks. But that challenge sets the scene, because the conversation that follows exposes precisely why independent journalism is now indispensable: the mainstream institutions we once trusted have become complicit in the very failures they should have interrogated.
From the outset, Foster is clear: none of the major COVID decisions were driven by evidence. Not the lockdowns, not hotel quarantine, not the obsessive daily case-counts blasted across TV screens. The knowledge needed to avoid the chaos already existed—decades of public-health understanding, pandemic modelling failures, and simple epidemiological common sense. Yet governments tossed it aside and copied China’s authoritarian template within weeks.
Allan reinforces this point: there was no data supporting lockdowns—none. The Diamond Princess cruise ship had already made it obvious that COVID overwhelmingly threatened the elderly, not the general population. But instead of targeted protection, governments unleashed blanket policies that crushed livelihoods, trampled liberties, and created the biggest wealth transfer from poor to rich in modern Australian history.
And when the consequences became undeniable—mental-health collapses, untreated cancers, educational damage, and a generation locked out of home ownership—politicians doubled down. Not one senior leader has admitted fault. Not one has apologised. According to Foster, the error is simply too big; they fear that telling the truth would destabilise public trust or even open them to legal liability.
The conversation also reveals how deeply the culture of fear was manufactured. Governments and media outlets ratcheted up anxiety using meaningless case numbers, unscientific “six-foot rules”, and ever-shifting mask mandates. Early treatments were suppressed, innovation discouraged, and dissenting experts punished. Instead of empowering front-line clinicians, bureaucrats dictated policy from ignorance—and Australia paid the price.
Perhaps most chilling is the trio’s shared warning: Australia remains primed to repeat every mistake. The proposed Australian Centre for Disease Control will only centralise power further. State governments are rewriting quarantine playbooks but still clinging to the same flawed assumptions. Treasury is tinkering with better ways to distribute emergency payments—an admission that they expect to use them again.
Nothing in the government’s response shows humility. Nothing shows learning. Nothing shows courage.
And as Coorey notes, the push for censorship—embodied by Julie Inman Grant’s eSafety regime—reveals a political class that prefers controlling speech to confronting its failures. A system that censors factual information to protect “narratives” is not preparing for better outcomes next time; it’s preparing to silence criticism when the next crisis arrives.
The episode ends with a sobering reminder: Australia’s greatest problem isn’t just political cowardice—it’s an apathetic public willing to accept it. Unless Australians demand better, nothing will change.
This is an episode worth watching in full. It’s urgent, important, and delivered with the clarity and candour that Damian Coorey has made his trademark.
WHAT DO YOU THINK? Add your comments below...
Damian Coory has spent 13 years as a senior radio and television journalist with the ABC, Network Ten, 3AW Melbourne, and 4BC Brisbane. Damian was News Director at Brisbane’s Triple M in the early 90s. Most recently he has 20 years’ experience in corporate public relations in Asia Pacific, specialising in executive communications skills training and coaching, issues management and crisis communications. He holds an MBA from Australia’s leading business school.


